I think I'm the only person here who hates the 360 controller lol I just cant stand the stupid D-pad and I've been spoiled by the PS3s built in battery. I just prefer the d-pads over analogue sticks in general (and most of the time the games associated with such :P). The Xbone controller does looks much improved though.
In my case I prefer the Saturn controller for fighters, but I wholeheartedly agree that it's the best for shumps =D, that and arcade games like power stone and cannon spike. They just fit so perfectly, DC is great for quick gaming sessions for that reason IMO.